New ICES advice: Do not eat eel

Scientific advice starkly contradicts continued fishing, consumption and restocking of European eel

6 November 2026 – The International Council for the Exploration of the Sea (ICES) has once again published its annual advice for European eel (Anguilla anguilla). Its conclusion remains unchanged and crystal clear: all human-induced mortality of eel must be reduced to zero. This includes commercial fishing, recreational fishing, aquaculture and the capture of glass eel for restocking programmes.

European eel has been listed as Critically Endangered on the IUCN Red List since 2008. Despite almost twenty years of European recovery measures, ICES still sees no evidence of a sustained recovery of the stock. Recruitment of young glass eel remains at a historically low level. According to the latest estimates, recruitment in the North Sea is just 1.2% of the level recorded during the 1960–1979 reference period.

According to Good Fish, the new advice once again confirms that there is currently no scientific basis for considering the consumption of European eel sustainable.

Glass eel restocking also lacks scientific justification

An important part of the debate surrounding eel management concerns the restocking of glass eel. Young eels are caught in areas where they enter coastal waters from the sea and are then subsequently released elsewhere. This practice is often presented as a conservation measure. However, ICES explicitly states in their advice that “The net benefit of restocking to the reproductive potential of the eel stock is unknown.”

According to ICES, crucial knowledge is lacking on factors including the carrying capacity of ecosystems, mortality during the restocking process, and the eventual contribution of released eel to reproduction. Although more eel may sometimes be observed locally following restocking, ICES states that its actual contribution to the spawning stock cannot be determined. ICES therefore concludes:
“Given the above-mentioned uncertainties and potential harmful effects, and consistent with the precautionary approach, no catch for restocking should be allowed.”

Large-scale exploitation continues

Despite the scientific advice, more than 1,500 tonnes of European eel were commercially landed in the European Union in 2025, almost one third of which was caught in Dutch waters. Glass eel is also still being caught for restocking programmes and aquaculture. ICES emphasises that not only fishing, but also other sources of human-induced mortality, such as pumping stations, hydropower plants, pollution and habitat loss, must be further reduced.

Time for policies that follow the science

Almost twenty years after the introduction of the European Eel Regulation, there is still no demonstrable recovery of the stock. Good Fish therefore calls for the management of European eel to be fully aligned with scientific advice. As long as ICES advises that all human-induced mortality must be reduced to zero and finds no scientific justification for catches intended for restocking, Good Fish believes there is only one logical conclusion:
Every eel that can keep swimming must be allowed to keep swimming.

Notes for editors

  • ICES advice link
  • Since 2021, ICES has advised zero catches of all life stages of eel, for all purposes and in all habitats.
  • The VISwijzer advises consumers not to buy European eel because of the critical state of the stock and the scientific advice to prevent human-induced mortality as much as possible.

Je gebruikt een verouderde browser. Hierdoor kunnen we de werking en veiligheid van de website niet garanderen. Bekijk hier de alternatieven.